Plato's Objection,
1. Yes, I am agree with the Plato's objection to freedom of expression and artistic liberty enjoyed by creative writer. There is so many movies which should be banned according to the Plato 's objection like
There is some advertisement which should be banned according to the Plato's law of objection. As we know that there is so many films or TV shops which are bad for the minor .May they take it personally ,there is so many creative serials that children can try and that is not good for them.
2 -If we see an example a book of Chetan Bharat name,"One Indian Girl. "to begin with the book highlights a feminist perspective, protagonist's (Radhika) struggles through the society and personal life,The book gives a major blow to the conservative Indian society where woman are underrated. Moreover... Chetan in a woman voice indirectly become a courage of many. This novel not gives only entertainment or pleasure to read but,it shows the reality of Indian society.narrowness of our mentality is the center of the novel but protagonist of story leads success.this is the good message for us. Thus, here m disagree with Plato's objection.
3 - If we see an example a book of Chetan Bharat name,"One Indian Girl. "to begin with the book highlights a feminist perspective, protagonist's (Radhika) struggles through the society and personal life,The book gives a major blow to the conservative Indian society where woman are underrated. Moreover... Chetan in a woman voice indirectly become a courage of many. This novel not gives only entertainment or pleasure to read but,it shows the reality of Indian society.narrowness of our mentality is the center of the novel but protagonist of story leads success.this is the good message for us. Thus, here m disagree with Plato's objection.
But in onther example a book name '
"Eleven minutes "by Paulo Coelho. The story of women name Maria,a young girl from Brazilian village.we can say merely a same girl struggle story like Chetan's book. But the way... Which choose by Maria is quiet different from the Radhika. In Paulo's this book I didn't find as good as the One Indian girl. I do not know if Coelho was trying to really get in the mindset by over analyzing sex, but I felt a real woman would be less philosophical and more emotional about her experience.
I just felt that what shocking things would come on her way.it was too dehumanized and how she handle the situation quite differently. Thus here m thinking that yes Plato is right that philosopher deals with idea/truth where poet deals with what appears to him/illusion.
4- In s.y.b.a.I have studied "Othello"by William Shakespeare. In this tragedy,Shakespeare didn't follow all the rules given by Aristotle but we can find Hamartia in tragic hero like his tragic flow is his credulity and jealousy, and then his tragic fall starts...
No comments:
Post a Comment