Monday, 20 November 2017

Coleridge

S T Coleridge gives his views to differentiate poem from prose in chapter 14 of biographialiteraria.
            he says that the difference between poem and prose must consist in the different object proposed. Some poems are made in metre or rhyme, but this is done only for remembering it. Coleridge says that the  poem is not only differentiate by using metre or rhyme with prose, but it would gives pleasure. The immediate object of poem is to give pleasure not the truth. On the other hand the immediate object of prose is to give the truth. He again differentiate poem from those prose whose objective is also to please the readers by saying that a poem must be a legitimate poem, means each and every single word of poem should explain and support the entire part of poem. There should be harmonious whole in poem.
In legitimate poem " the reader should be carried forward, not merely or chiefly by the mechanical impulse of curiosity or by the pleasurable activity of mind exited by the abstractions of the journey itself".
  
Helpe then, O holy Virgin chiefe of nine,                Thy weaker Novice to performe thy will;
  Lay forth out of thine everlasting scryne
  The antique rolles, which there lye hidden still,
  Of Faerie knights[*] and fairest Tanaquill
  Whom that most noble Briton Prince[*] so long                   
  Sought through the world, and suffered so much ill,
  That I must rue his undeserved wrong:
O helpe thou my weake wit, and sharpen my dull tong.
n the above canto Queen Elizabeth ask for help to the holly knight. She wants to sent him into the forest where there is a devil. She wants that knight to fight with the devil and killed him. In this lines of the poem there is not only the curiosity of the reader and restless desire to arrive at the final solution that what should this holy knight do, whether he get success in killing the demon in the forest or not, but also the there arise the pleasurable activity of the mind excited by the abstractions of the journey itself.


Poem and Poetry-


Coleridge not only distinguished prose with poems but poetry with poems also. He says that the poetry is a wider than poem, it brings the whole soul of the man. He differentiate poetry with poetic genius. He further explain that poetry of the highest kind may exist without metre and even without the contradistinguishing object of a poem.
"poetry for coleridge is an activity of the poets mind and a poem is merely one of its expression"
the best example which supports this definition of poetry is of William butler yeats's sailing to Byzantium'


An aged man is but a paltry thing,
A tattered coat upon a stick, unless
Soul clap its hands and sing, and louder sing
For every tatter in its mortal dress,
Nor is there singing school but studying
Monuments of its own magnificence;
And therefore I have sailed the seas and come
To the holy city of Byzantium.


In the above stanza of the poetry the poet describes the present situation of his country. He says that there is corruption everywhere. Thus he wants to sail to the holy city Byzantium. In this poetry the poet covers much wider topics and it is successively presents the activity of the poets mind


Robinson Crusoe

���� introduction : 
           Robinson Crusoe is 18th century novel by Daniel Defoe . it was.  published in 1719 . it is an adventure story of character Robinson Crusoe . it was among one of the most widely punished books . we seen many social issues in this novel . 
            The character of this novel are Robinson Crusoe , Friday , Xury , The Portuguese captain , The Spaniard .
���� Colonial discourse in Robinson Crusoe :
               England was for a long while , by far the most powerful and widely spread colonial empire in the world Portugal was , at once time , a dominant colonial force in Europe , as was Spain in defo's Robinson Crusoe , colonialism is clearly apparent .
                Crusoe gives a Christian name ' Friday ' who was nigro people of that island . Crusoe starts relationship between him and Friday as a ' MASTER - SLAVE ' and Crusoe called Friday as a ' MY MAN ' . Crusoe teach Friday to his English language . 
               Crusoe tells Friday to wear clothes but Friday was uncomfortable in wearing clothes . Crusoe started teaching his own Christian religion to Friday Crusoe tells him that his god is superior than his god .
���� How colonialism works in our life :
          After independence we have so much changes are held . the some celebration of birthday and engagements imposed by Britishers . colonialism of food and clothes are raised with trend in India and clothes are raised with trend in India which are most followed by people .
���� The movie is different than the original text in so many ways : 
1: Movie focus only on one aspect , there are many other things like repenting dis obeying his parents , the whole life of Crusoe that is not presenter in film .
2: in text when Crusoe trying to imposed his god , Friday get convinced easily without any argument , but in movie reflects the Friday doesn't consider to him and then he began argue with him .
3: in the novel when Crusoe tells Friday to go back to his own land , Friday started apologising he feels that he had done something wrong that's why his master did not need him any more . in the film there is total opposite situation Crusoe needs Friday's company , his friendship .
���� Anti - Colonialism elements :
               The change in the film shows anti-colonial element of nature . Crusoe wants to become Friday's friend . the chemistry of their relation is shown in the film .
           We can see strong bond between Crusoe and Friday . The original novel is written in 1719 while the movie is in 1997 and changing of time is reason that movie show anti - colonial elements .


        Thank You .


Post truth

When we talk about the POST-TRUTH its hide real situation and it is not presents the reality of the society .The people also live in some kind of   assumption  that is is  truth. The truth means something exist in the society but the POST-TRUTH is retelling the truth which canbe truth or not. We see in the media tht how they hide the reality of people so people is live in some kind of ignorance but in the real life but it is not truth.
              Truth is always about that exist or we can say the facts which are there. On the other hand post truth is ‘‘created truth’. the famous  phrase about truth is ‘’universal truth’’. But POST-TRUTH is an individual truth , which one believes and when that person convince others to accept the same belief by force or in a very polite way, and if people accept that as something  ‘real’ or ‘true’, it is not.
“POST- TRUTH” era is an era which changes the perception of truth by implying that “truth is not one” but it differs person to person. The  term is related with the idea of ‘many truths’ and all want their truths should be accepted by society.in the era of POST-TRUTH all answers are true because all have different opinions with their own right side.
             Example can be the molestation of girls. There is a problem in the psyche of those males who molest girls. But some political leaders and other citizens have implied that the reason is short cloths of girls for this kind of molestation. This was repeated  by most of people in india and that’s why it was widely accepted also.
The term ‘’post truth’’ is designed to elicit a sense of moral superiority in those who still support the globalist agenda. It is consistent with the elitist character of the globalist,whose rhetorical sr ategy has been to praise its supporters as ‘enligtend’ and condemn its opponents as stupid and evil.

Wordsworth

What is the basic difference between the poetic creed of 'Classicism' and 'Romanticism'?
Romanticism and classicism they are two different ideologies or 'school of thought'. And given idea about dominance of certain things. 


Classicism:in classicism aesthetic attitude and principals manifested in the art architecture and literature if ancient Greece and Rome and characterized by emphasis on form simplicity proportion and restraint. Romanticism: Romanticism was an artistic literary musical and intellectual movement that originated in Europe towards the end of 18th century. 


Difference between classicism and romanticism is that classicism put out restrictions,whereas romanticism believes in liberty. Classicism presents urban life , whereas romanticism presents rural life. classicism believe on subjectivity and romanticism believes in objectivity. classicism is about intellectual and romanticism is about imagination .


➤ Why does Wordsworth say 'What' is poet? rather than Who is poet?


A poet is man speaking to men, a man, it is true, endued with more lively sensibility, more enthusiasm and tenderness,


Who has a greater knowledge of human nature, and a more comprehensive soul, than are supposed to be common among mankind. 


Wordsworth has greater knowledge of human nature through the emotions like observation, heightened. He also uses platonic, more comprehensive soul. 


➤  What is poetic diction? Which sort of poetic diction is suggested by Wordsworth in his Preface?


Poetic diction means 'Choice of Word'- unique style of authors that he or she chooses his or her own language, which is understood by rustic people; who closure to reality and more genuineness the language should be natural not ornamental. Wordsworth's argument is that he is interested in writing poems in lyrical ballads. And the language "as really used by men". Wordsworth also answers to Coleridge that he finds humble and rustic life, a men who closer to reality or more genuineness. Wordsworth preferred rustic men rather than city dwells.


➤ What is poetry?


 Wordsworth's  definition of poetry  :
    " Poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings it takes origin from emotion recollected in tranquility. "


   Wordsworth portrays his idea about poetry in this definition that poet is the most comprehensive soul and far better human being than ordinary people. so, the poet is the teacher and through the medium of of poetry he imparts moral lessons for the betterment of human life.


➤  Discuss 'Daffodils - I wandered lonely as a cloud' with reference to Wordsworth's poetic creed.
  'Daffodils' is the best example of Wordsworth's definition of poetry “poetry is a spontaneous overflow of a powerful feeling, recollected in tranquility". We all see the beauty of nature by our different point of views  but we cannot recollect and express that delight in tranquility.  so, we can call Wordsworth as nature poet, by recalling his memory and sensibility and by observing the nature, Wordsworth wrote his poetry. 


Dryden

Dryden's Thinking Activity


1) Do you find any difference between Aristotle's definition of Tragedy and Dryden's definition of Play?


first see both the definition,
Aristotle's definition


"Tragedy, then is an art of imitation of an certain that is serious, complete and of a certain magnitude; in the language embellished with each kind of artistic ornament. The several kinds being found in separate parts of the play; in the form of action not of narrative; through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation catharsis of these and no emotions."


Dryden's definition


"A play ought to be a just and lively image of human nature, representing its passion and humors and the changes of fortune to which it is subjected, for the delight and instruction of mankind"


We can see diffrence from the very starting of the definition, Aristotle starts with word "Tragedy" while wordsworth starts with "The play" which shows that Aristotle only give definition of Tragedies while wordsworth speaks about The Play in general. In Aristotle's definition there is words used like "pity", "fear", "catharsis" this all words shows inaway a delight through sad emotions while wordsworth's definition talk about "Delight" which includes all kind of delight. These are some visible difference in both definition.


2) If you are supposed to give your personal predilection, would you be on the side of the Ancient or the Modern? Please give reasons.


I would rather prefer to go with the moderns, yes ancients are important but it doesn't mean that we stuck to them if we will stuck at one point we will die we have to move on and this is the reason I will go with moderns because they always add something new to the work of ancients and yes moderns are sit on the back of ancients and they can see far because inaway they are at height.


Aristotle's poetics

 Q.1-  How far do you agree with Plato’s objection to freedom of expression and artistic liberty enjoyed by creative writers? Name the texts (novels, plays, poems, movies, TV soaps etc which can be rightfully objected and banned with reference to Plato’s objections) 


(1-A).I agree Plato's objection to freedom of expression is true because some kind of serials ,advertisement and literary text is not good aspect for examples are
➨Ahaliya-indra, kunti's children and many other's things
.
➨Sony tv serial "Bharat ka veer putar 'Maharana pratap" .
In real life Maharana Pratap and Akbar never came face to face with each other. But here the two have been fighting each other ever since they were kid. Like every other serial, this serial Forget history, the serial just like any other contemporary TV show is full of saas bahu saajish and melodrama.
➨In the tragedy "Othello" by William Shakespeare During the drama the audience finds itself in concepts of love,hate,jealousy.Othello killed his wife.
➨Advertisements of "Domino's pizza" and other advertisements .97% of all food advertised to all food advertised to make children's unhealthy levels of fat, sugar,or salt.
So I agree with Plato's objection.


Q.2.  With reference to the literary texts you have studied during B.A. programme, write brief note on the texts which followed Aristotelian literary tradition (i.e. his concept of tragedy, catharsis, tragic hero with hamartia etc)
 
(2-A).Aristotle defines tragedy as, “the imitation of an action that is serious and also has moving magnitude, complete in itself; in appropriate and pleasurable language… in a dramatic rather than narrative form; with incidents arousing pity and fear, where with to accomplish a catharsis of emotions”, . These are unique qualities which can be in Othello. The story starting with the main character and protagonist Othello, an African general for the Venice army. Othello has just married his wife Desdemona. Throughout the play Othello is challenged by Iago who works under him. Iago provides the drama; he represents the antagonist.Nothing good becomes of this play. By the end of this tragedy, both Othello and Desdemona are dead.


Q.3.  With reference to the literary texts you have studies during B.A. programme, write brief note on the texts which did NOT follow Aristotelian literary tradition. (i.e. his concept of tragedy, catharsis, tragic hero with hamartia etc.)
 
(3-A.) Harry Ape as a modern tragedy does not follow the theory of Aristotle. Yank the hero has no hamartia as he is not a man of highrank . there are the action not external but internal.


Q.4.  Have you studied any tragedies during B.A. programme? Who was/were the tragic protagonist/s in those tragedies? What was their ‘hamartia’?
 
(4-A). Othello by william shakespeare tragedy I study in my B.A pogramme.follow necessary rules and regulations proposed bAristotle's definition of tragic hero othello follow this definition and not only othello reprsent a hero as a general of an army ,he is the main character of the play.he draws compassion and sympathy from the audience making him the tragic hero.


5. Did the ‘Plot’ of those tragedies follow necessary rules and regulations proposed by Aristotle? (Like chain of cause and effect, principle of probability and necessity, harmonious arrangement of incidents, complete, certain magnitude, unity of action etc)
(5-A)."othello" follow necessary rules and regulations proposed by Aristotle


Hamlet

1.How faithful is the movie to the original play?
√…Movie is quite faithful to the play, because it has followed the text well, but it has also "a creative  touch"  by the director, and in scenes like the conversation between ghost and Hamlet, Hamlet's rude behavior  towards Ophelia, we can notice it is very well directed and performed, it can express emotions as well as by imagination while reading.


2.After watching the movie, have your perception about play, characters or situations changed?
√…At some point it has changed my perception about the play. While reading we can imagine the different kind of situations and scenes of the play, but after watching the movie we come to know about how the dialogues were delivered, and after observing  the expressions, we conclude the interpretation more effectively.  It has given a perfect support to the play to get proper meaning.


3.Do you feel ‘aesthetic delight’ while watching the movie? If yes, exactly when did it happen? If no, can you explain with reasons?
√…Yes,this is tragic play, though I felt 'aesthetic delight' while i have watched some comic scenes of Hamlet and when there is a scene of Ophelia and Hamlet when they were happy, we can also feel delight when Hamlet recalls his memories with his father. Aesthetic delight can be found in tragic scene also, when Hamlet saw the ghost of his father and had a talk with him.


4.Do you feel ‘catharsis’ while or after watching movie? If yes, exactly when did it happen? If no, can you explain with reasons?
√…Yes, I felt 'catharsis' in such scenes like:  when Hamlet come to know about his father's murder by  his uncle and mother, when Hamlet is frustrated and he behaves cruelly with Ophelia, In the scene in which Ophelia had gone mad and his brother came, when Hamlet dies.


5.Does screening of movie help you in better understanding of the play?
√…Yes it is very much useful to get the play properly and in right way. At one point it can power up our imagination to get the setting, situations and the mind set of character by his expression.  Audio visuals can effect more than 'Only reading', as we can remember easily what we have seen than what we have read.


6.Was there any particular scene or moment in the movie that you will cherish lifetime?
√…There are many scenes in the play which are very beautifully directed, but the scene in which Hamlet follows the ghost and the whole conversation is beautifully directed, there is various emotions mingled together, there is delight, terror, revenge, shock and the feeling of hatred in the eyes of Hamlet, and the expression of the ghost and his effective voice, his tone is so effective.


7.If you are director, what changes would you like to make in the remaking of movie on Shakespeare’s ‘Hamlet’?
√…I feel that there is no need any changes in movie. Because movie is wonderfully presented by Kenneth Branagh. Movie is also faithful to play so I feel that there is no need any changes.


8.In the beginning of the movie, camera rolls over the statue of King Hamlet out side the Elsinore castle. The movie ends with the similar sequence wherein the statue of the King Hamlet is hammered down to the dust. What sort of symbolism do you read in this?
√…Symbolism is one of the narrative technique. Director use very well this technique in his movie. The first and the last scene of the kings statue outside the castle symbolizes the ' circle of life'. Power never remains stagnant. It keeps on changing. Downfall is necessary to know the real value of power.


9.While studying the play through movie, which approach do you find more applicable to the play? Why? Give reasons with illustrations.
√…We can observe many approaches in one on the other way. I feel that psychological and formalist approach is more applicable. In such scenes of play Hamlet is with his mother and when he is going to take such decision towards his revenge with Claudius, many times he finds himself helpless. In formalist approach, all about trapping each other.


10.Which of the above mentioned approaches (in Pre-viewing task) appeals you more than other?Why? Give reasons.
√…In the play, formalist approach is appeals me more than any other approach. There is vast difference between "seeming" and "being" in all the major characters like Hamlet, Claudius and Gertrude. All are pretend as they are right and good but all has some kind of devilish intention. There is a question of " knowability" of characters in play.

Paper no : 15 Assignment

Assignment Name: Mori Utsavi Bharatbhai Roll No. : 33 Enrolment No. : 2069108420180037 M.A.Sem: 4 Year: 2017-2019 Email id:...